This hasn't exactly been a great debate yet but I can see it becoming one, so I'd value everyone's input.
Long story short, this current blue/grey/black skin is called AcidTech Blue and it's more or less a very default skin for PHPBB forums/boards. What this means is, despite nostalgia and what WWE-Clubbers are accustomed to, this is not an original skin. There are likely hundreds of boards out there that use this exact skin/theme and you'd not be able to tell the difference other than the site header/logo. Personally I hate that idea. I feel we're one of the best communities that exist on a forum platform and we should NOT be using something that any Tom Dick or Harry can instantly choose from a list. I'm also not fond of muddy murky grey with sky blue, it's insulting to my nearly feminine color/art/interior design molded mentality.
I can, and highly desire, to create or heavily modify a different skin to become fully original and separate us from the old WWE-Club. It can be similar, just not exactly the same. However, what I want and feel may not be the same as the collective community, so I'm putting this up for vote.
Choose what you will and give your reasoning if possible. Thank you, folks!