New York Pizza or Chicago Pizza?

[JDD]

Me and HFX and some other people debated this in the SB a few weeks back. Would like to know everyones opinion on it. For me its New York pizza all the way. All though i could be biased living in New York but nothing is better then a really great slice of new york pizza for me.

[Enygma]

Chicago for me.

[ShaneOfan]

New York all day, keep that deep dish shit away

[Viazon]

What exactly is the difference?

[Ali]

I've never had authentic New York Pizza in New York, but the New York Style is very easily done by a lot of people. In fact, I'm having New York Style Pizza tonight, made by actual Italians who I would not hesitate to believe came to Dallas via NYC.

But that, to me, is why Chicago Pizza is better. I can't get Chicago Style Deep Dish in Dallas, and having actually been to Chicago, eating Deep Dish in Chicago is absolutely wonderful. I can't get that anywhere but Chicago.

This may all change whenever I actually go to NYC and eat at Lombardi's, but for now, Chicago wins.

[GNR]

Chicago Pizza >>>>>>>

[iMike]

Chicago Pizza >>>>>>>

That's why we're friends GNR.

[UTK]

I've never had authentic New York Pizza in New York, but the New York Style is very easily done by a lot of people.

No, it is not. Not by a long shot.

[HFX]

When I eat pizza I want a meal which means I want a good sized pie. Chicago Deep Dish is the king of pizzas for that reason. It is filling as well as having great crust. New York Pizza is still good but I'd only choose it over Chicago if I was on the go and had to eat in a hurry.

[SlightlyJames]

By most accounts I've never had the greatest form of either so I'm abstaining from the vote until I have.

[HFX]

I declare Chicago Pizza the winner with 60% of the vote.

[Viazon]

I still don't know the difference.

[Everlong]

It's not even close, Chicago by a landslide.

Also, New York's case isn't helped by all the NYC food snobs who visit other places and are like "EVERYTHING IS SO MUCH BETTER IN NEW YORK BLAH BLAH BLAH."

This reminds me of a joke. How do you know if someone has lived in New York? DON'T WORRY, THEY'LL FUCKING TELL YOU.

[Locke]

I still don't know the difference.

Same here. I like a good stuffed crust pizza from Pizza Hut, all meat toppings. That to me is unbeatable. But I've never been to Chicago or NYC and hopefully never will.

[SKS]

Chicago is deep dish, New York is thin.

I like both. I lean towards my home style since I'm in Jersey. Brick oven pizza is my favorite.

[Locke]

Chicago is deep dish, New York is thin.

I like both. I lean towards my home style since I'm in Jersey. Brick oven pizza is my favorite.

I thought it was more than that, like Chicago used a different cheese than mozzarella.

If it's DEEP vs THIN, well, DEEP all the freakin' way. Thin is crap.

[Chewy]

I thought NY had the pizza pie and Chicago was deep dish?

Either way I will pick Chicago because New York is fucking lame.

[VaderBomb]

Never been huge on Deep Dish, I actually prefer thin crust pies.

[UTK]

[The Legend]

The crust is my least favorite part of the pizza therefore it's New York style all the way.