PorkChop wrote:The main problem I have was that we've been a wrestling forum before, and we failed. Most of our user base here were part of a wrestling forum which ran for 11 years, and barely had any traffic whatsoever - particularly over the past 5 years or so.
There are several reasons why WWE-Club failed. It was poorly moderated and Bryan was against almost any ideas of expansion/evolving. Despite that, WWE-Club still did generate a lot of traffic - the problem is people weren't joining. There was no homepage, the interface was out of style, so on and so forth. Nothing to attract people to the forum. I am confident we won't repeat those same mistakes. Still, the WWE-Club was successful. I can't speak on the activity in its early days (2004-2006, whatever it may be), but several people still joined. I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure you came after me, so did Locke, Philip Rivers, NoDQ, xgamr, etc. It is effective. We just need to keep pushing rather than be content like Bryan and Crissay (who was very active when I first joined and then stopped showing up).
The issue with MainEventForums is that, while it caters to more than one group of people, the title itself isn't specific enough. "Wrestling" in the name is likely to get us far more traffic than "MainEventForums". I can truly say I wouldn't have joined WWE-Club if I didn't know it was a wrestling site. Probably wouldn't have clicked on it.
There is reason wrestlingforum is as active as it is. It isn't because they have huge financial funding (reddit) or quality that much better than ours. They have a name that is to the point and attracts a lot of traffic while also having a continually updated homepage. More traffic = more members = more activity = forum gets around and more well-known.
Also, the more members we have, the more likely we will be getting people who are fans of MMA and boxing. We won't be de-emphasizing the sports section or anything like that. Just placing more of an emphasis on wrestling and presenting ourselves to outside eyes as a wrestling forum. I think we should try to be specific.