I don't get it.
He's got a solid look. He's a great worker, especially when paired with someone who can compliment his rough style. His matches against Barrett and Bryan for example were great. He can talk, he's not the best but he's certainly not the worst.
His entrance is fucking boss. I don't get the hate he gets. His current boring program could be placed at the feet of Orton rather than Sheamus. Orton has notoriously dragged angles and feuds down by just being his boring robotic self.