It's Here Comes The Pain for me. I also thought the backyard wrestling games were underrated. The second one especially. I think the sequel had New Jack in it and that made me lol.
I liked Shut Your Mouth and Here Comes The Pain for the cool backstage stuff you could do during season mode. You could wrestle through all the PPVs and interfere in matches and form stables and make decisions and crap. Talk to the GM and ask for a title shot, talk shit to people in the hallways. Then they went to the shitty 3 month story lines that make all your decisions for you.
My favorite will always be WM 19 for Gamecube. Revenge Mode was fucking amazing. Tossing people off the dock, slamming construction workers off buildings into oblivion, I loved it.
Hell, even the TNA game wasn't that bad.
0
OH SQUARED CIRCLE, DON'T YOU DARE BE SOURRRRRR! CLAP ALONG WITH YOUR TAG CHAMPS, AND FEEL THE POWAHHHHHHHH!
I'm stuck in the wwe immortal game right now. Play it multiple times a day trying to rank my players up but its like some people online either spents thousands on downloads or hacked the game cause some of the players are insane.